
author: Susan Mallery
published: 3.18.2025
publisher: Canary Street Press
genre(s): contemporary
pages: 370
source: library
format: eBook
buy/shelve it: Amazon | B&N | Kobo | BookBub | BookHype | StoryGraph | Goodreads
rating:

the blurb
What would you do if you caught your brother cheating on your best friend?
While Beth is proud of her Malibu beach shop, Surf Sandwiches, she's even prouder of her charismatic brother, Rick, who rose from foster care all the way through surgical residency. She makes subs, he saves lives. Things takes a turn for the happy after she finds out Rick is dating her new best friend, Jana. Then Jana’s handsome brother adds even more sparkle to Beth’s days…and nights.
But when she catches Rick with another woman—like, with with—her visions of an idyllic family future disappear in one awful instant. Either she betrays her brother or she keeps his secret and risks losing the man she loves and her best friend.
Love and loyalty collide with secrets and betrayal in this witty and emotional tale about the lengths we’ll go to for family, from Susan Mallery, bestselling author of The Boardwalk Bookshop.
a few notes
POV: 3rd person
setting: Malibu, CA
keywords/phrases: beach, family, divorce, dysfunction, betrayal
tropes: interpersonal relationship conflict, family drama
spice: 3/5🔥🔥🔥
language: 2/5🤬🤬
mood reading: in the mood for angsty family/friend conflict in a beautiful setting
bonus points: Kai, the early 20’s surfer who’s an old soul
my review
I went into this expecting a summery, beach read that was light on the angst. But this was not that. Instead, it was a story of secrets, questionable decisions, and a whole lot of betrayal.
The themes in this were deep and highly relatable for many of us. At the forefront was the hard choice between loyalty and doing the right thing in a given situation. The author further complicates it by adding a divided loyalty into the mix. That created an incredibly messy, complex dynamic which felt all too real. With it comes the notion of blind loyalty and the ways that can completely encompass how people can view those close to them. There are some deeply twisted dynamics in this book, and it made for a great read.
If I had a complaint, it would be the way in which the two women are able to be surprised by their shared connection. It just seems unrealistic that, in conversation, no one would mention a name. It seemed glaring enough that it took a star for me because I just couldn’t get past that.
Rating Report | |
---|---|
plot | |
characters | |
writing | |
pacing | |
Overall: | ![]() |
Reading this book contributed to these challenges:
- 2025 52 Books Reading Challenge
Leave a Reply