author: Moïra Fowley-Doyle
published: 7 August 2018
genre(s): magical realism
buy/shelve it: Amazon | B&N | BookBub | BookHype | Goodreads
One stormy Irish summer night, Olive and her best friend, Rose, begin to lose things. It starts with simple items like hairclips and jewelry, but soon it's clear that Rose has lost something much bigger, something she won't talk about, and Olive thinks her best friend is slipping away.
Then seductive diary pages written by a girl named Laurel begin to appear all over town. And Olive meets three mysterious strangers: Ivy, Hazel, and her twin brother, Rowan, secretly squatting in an abandoned housing estate. The trio are wild and alluring, but they seem lost too--and like Rose, they're holding tight to painful secrets.
When they discover the spellbook, it changes everything. Damp, tattered and ancient, it's full of hand-inked charms to conjure back things that have been lost. And it just might be their chance to find what they each need to set everything back to rights.
Unless it's leading them toward things that were never meant to be found...
content warning: rape, sexual harassment
a few notes
public reading: safe for the public eye
cover notes: beautiful and mysterious
keywords/phrases: LGBTQIA+, magic, family dysfunction, witchy
mood reading: in the mood for something surreal
bonus points: LGBTQIA+ characters, treatment of virginity
anti-bonus points: the handling of rape and sexual harassment
This book truly captured the mood and tone of what magical realism should be. It is both haunting and beautiful, both hopeful and dark. The lines between what is real and what is otherworldy are perfectly blurred. And the writing is lush and lyrical, pulling the reader into the story. The narrative was so creative, with an almost abstract quality to it. Nothing is solid or stable. No one is reliable. Nothing can be trusted. The story wavers as you read it, shifting between the real and the magical.
The premise was so interesting and unique, told through multiple perspectives and timelines which come together in a surprising way. Things are being lost, and at first, few think much of it. Sometimes, it’s small, inconsequential things. Other times, the things being lost are less tangible but more significant. At the same time, things are also being found… both tangible and intangible. It’s a story that asks questions, of the characters and of the reader. Are the consequences of what you gain worth what you lost? How much can you lose before you lose yourself?
I love the LGBTQIA+ representation. There are two bisexual girls and one lesbian, none of which are all that prevalent in YA lit. Was there a little bit of insta love between two of the girls? Yes, maybe. But I don’t count that as an anti-bonus point because that is often just a part of life for teenagers.
One of my favorite things was that the author firmly removed the pedestal upon which female virginity is placed. Virginity wasn’t painted as some kind of precious gift; it wasn’t used as a measure of a girl’s worth. I loved the empowerment of that.
I didn’t altogether love the way rape and sexual harasment was treated. It felt as if it wasn’t given the significance that kind of trauma deserves, touched on very superficially. There was little exploration of how it really affected the character, and the way the offender was handled seemed a touch lazy. Nor was there any real conclusion to that part of the plot. It seemed as if the whole thing was just used as a device to give that character purpose in the main plot of the story.
Maybe every first is a loss.p. 228
Maybe we need to lose some things to make room for others. The everyday things we let go of so we can move on with a lighter load.p.347
A few other otherworldly magical realism novels for you!
Reading this book contributed to these challenges:
- 2022 Library Love Reading Challenge
- 2022 Linz the Bookworm Reading Challenge
- 2022 PopSugar Reading Challenge